A little peanut butter knowledge for you: it takes about 850 peanuts to produce and 18 ounce jar of peanut butter. Natural peanut butter uses only peanuts and oil, usually peanut oil. Peanut butter is sold in two forms - smooth and chunky. Natural peanut butter must be refrigerated after opening and can be stored up to 6 months. (Food Lovers Companion)
My first official reView is in. After 4 salty, crunchy, and monounsaturated fat filled months of taste testing various brands of peanut butter, I have finally decided on a winner. This would be my first, and definitely not last, attempt at truly investing quality time into finding the perfect brand of a food. At times, I questioned why I was taste testing a food that was the subject of many breaking news stories, due to the contaminated ingredient of the peanut, that was causing deaths amongst the United States population. Granted, peanut butter is still on the safe list and we really not need worry about harming ourselves during consumption. Therefore, the project continued on.
Over the past few months I have made some definite conclusions about the topic of peanut butter. The first being that there are quite a few peanut butter fanatics in the city of Chicago that I interact with on a daily basis. When you find someone that enjoys peanut butter, they just don't 'kind-of' like it to the point where they could live with or without it, but instead they are an 'absolutely have to have in on a daily basis' sort of peanut butter lover. Each person has their favorite brand. Some like crunchy and some prefer creamy. Others like all natural while many enjoy the separated varieties. Regardless, I have enjoyed talking peanut butter over the past few months with just about anyone that will listen.
I created a system to judge each brand. My first rule was that I would not buy a peanut butter that contained sugar in the ingredient list. I like my peanut butter sans sugar and since it was my experiment, I can make up my own rules. I kept a hand-written detailed list about each brand that I was investigating. I took notes on the following to make my decision: ingredients, creaminess, roasted quality of the nuts, saltiness, texture, and quality of butter after refrigeration. I graded each one with a letter grade from A-F.
In the end I probably could have taste-tested even a few more brands, but once I came across my winner I knew it was the one. I didn't want to spend any other time tasting inferior butters, but instead wanted to just go with the winner on a full-time basis. I love peanut butter with apples or spread on toast with a chopped banana. It is great spread over vanilla ice cream and can make a killer ingredient in cookie. I've mentioned that I love it on oatmeal and could honestly eat it on cardboard.
I hope you enjoy this inaugural reView. If you are a peanut butter lover, please share your favorite brand with me.
MaraNatha Organic Crunchy Peanut Butter w/salt
-Ingredients: peanuts, salt
-Notes: MN has a creamy texture that you could compare to a Skippy or Jiff, even though it is a crunchy peanut butter. The roasted peanut flavor does not come through. The taste is almost bland. The quality is not there. The chopped peanuts throughout the mixture are sparse. The peanut butter stays creamy after refrigeration and is easy to spread.
Grade: C-
Fresh Ground Crunchy Peanut Butter from Whole Foods
-Ingredients: peanuts, salt
-Notes: Peanut butter has a very thick texture. There is a strong roasted peanut flavor. The texture is creamy but still has that crunchy bite to it as you start to taste it. The chopped peanuts don't dissolve in your mouth as you chew, but instead stay on your tongue for flavor. The mixture needs more salt. The thick mixture is still easily pliable after a few days in the fridge.
Grade: B
Smuckers Natural Chunky Peanut Butter
-Ingredients: peanuts, salt
-Notes: Smuckers peanut butter has both a chunky and grainy texture. This butter requires you to stir upon opening to mix it up. The chopped peanuts floating on top get distributed throughout the mixture, which is a great addition. There is a strong roasted peanut flavor. It is both creamy as you put it in your mouth but then nutty as you start to chew. There is a good salt content.
Grade: A-
Arrowhead Mills Crunchy Valencia Peanut Butter
-Ingredients: roasted peanuts
=Notes: Arrowhead Mills has a butter with a creamy texture much like the MaraNatha brand. The roasted peanut flavor is there but the mixture is lacking flavor and salt. Like Skippy, the butter stays quite creamy after being in the fridge for a week but it does not have that bite that peanut butter should have. This peanut butter is just lacking in texture and taste.
Grade: C
Trader Joe's Organic Crunchy Peanut Butter
-Ingredients: dry roasted peanuts, salt
-Notes: TJ has a great peanut taste. The texture is smooth but still has that crunchy aftertaste that create a nice afterthought. The peanut butter has a good salty taste but is lacking that standout taste. In a pinch this would do. I also tried the TJ crunchy peanut butter with flax seeds but because that throws in a little twist, I didn't review that in this experiment. I do however prefer the butter with flax seeds as opposed to this one.
Grade: B+

Santa Cruz Organic Dark Roasted Crunchy Peanut Butter
-Ingredients: peanuts salt
-Notes: At first, Santa Cruz peanut butter has a great creamy texture. Once stirred, the peanuts combine with the smooth mixture to make for a great peanut taste. The salt content is slightly lacking. After refrigeration, the butter turns rock solid. It is not spreadable and loses that roasted flavor.
Grade: B-
7 Peanut Butters later and a winner has been declared......
365 Crunchy Peanut Butter
-Ingredients: peanuts, salt
-Notes: 365 peanut butter has a multitude of crunchy peanuts throughout the mixture, optimizing flavor throughout. There is a great salt taste, and the peanut flavor stays on your tongue. It is creamy without being too smooth. The mixture spreads easily yet doesn't run all over your food. The peanut butter has a great texture that really allows you to enjoy the roasted peanut flavor.
Grade: A+
When first going into the project, my peanut butter of choice was the Smucker's All Natural. I didn't think I would find one that I enjoyed more than that one. I will not be doing back. You must try this 365 brand. To each his own. The average person will have a different liking to each of the peanut butters that I have reviewed. But that is ok; this is what makes the world go round. I'm glad that I can spend my 365 days a year with Whole Foods 365 crunchy peanut butter.